Although not, the dating strained whenever John ran aside having little more than a year immediately after delivering Abigail Roberts pregnant along with his boy, Jack
Towards the end of the section Arthur is in a stand out of which have Micah and you may informs everybody in the gang that he’s the newest rodent and also started helping the Pinkertons. Yet not, Dutch is initial indecisive on whom to think but ends up directing his guns at Arthur and John. Pinkertons after that arrived at the new gang’s hide-out and you may a beneficial shootout starts, John and you will Arthur flee because of a cavern or over a hill, where Dutch, Micah, Cleet and you will Joe begin chasing her or him. If your pro helps to make the choice to greatly help John, Arthur find losing themselves to save John. Arthur’s last encounter having Dutch is just after the guy and you may Micah possess a brawl and Arthur, who’s running and you will rarely alive out of his tuberculosis, is about to make the gun and you can kill him simply for Dutch, which unexpectedly seems, to stop him. Arthur’s past terms to help you Dutch would be the fact Micah are a rat and then he knows it. He emotionally tells Dutch he “provided your all he previously.” Even with Micah’s pleas to own Dutch to come with your on the currency the guy converts and you will guides out, Arthur searching to possess ultimately convinced your. Arthur then becomes deceased and you can, according to their prize height, it can be regarding Micah eliminating your otherwise soundly succumbing to their tuberculosis.
John Marston
Arthur and you may John was, mostly, eg brothers because they both was in fact raised by the Dutch and Hosea getting fifteen years. This hurt Arthur significantly and you can remaining your feeling betrayed and get mad at the John maybe not admiring your family he had. Consequently, for the majority of out-of 1899, Arthur features nothing regard to own John. The guy points out which had anybody else ran from such as the guy did they won’t were welcomed back, and further means that he believes Dutch coddles him excessive. Regardless of this, the two work nicely with her and you can Arthur may have charming conversations having him around camp.
In early stages, Arthur, alongside Javier, rescues John immediately after the guy had shed and you may attacked by the a package from wolves you to definitely will leave John along with his famous marks. Soon after, Arthur shows just a bit of esteem to have John immediately after he arrives with a decide to deprive a train. The theory visibly impresses Arthur and statements that he is brand new earliest kid to own half of his notice eaten by the wolves and you can come-out wiser. not, Arthur nevertheless becomes annoyed by John’s terrible behavior, including once they, also Javier, discount horses in the Braithwaites having, what they wished might possibly be $5,100000, just to find out they might score $650. Despite the much less currency John allows, having Arthur getting in touch with him a fool.
There are many minutes on the facts whenever Arthur and John bicker, such 
as for example, when John gets Arthur’s help to inexpensive specific sheep to market from inside the Valentine the two shall be read arguing in the Jack, which have John complaining you to definitely Arthur grabbed your fishing in accordance with Arthur answering one John might be spending more time together with his family relations, specifically Jack. It absolutely was about same business you to Arthur conserves your after he had been captured from the Leviticus Cornwall’s men and you may held on gun section, but Arthur, because of their access to Lifeless Eye, seems to kill them before they could do just about anything.
Whenever Jack was kidnapped from the Braithwaite family unit members, and you will after that died in order to Angelo Bronte, Arthur manage guarantees John you to definitely everything would be ok. The guy praises John to have keeping calm and compiled as much as Bronte when negotiating getting Jack’s return. If the gang properly score John’s kid to camp the guy thanks Arthur getting his help, Arthur informs John to invest date together with his loved ones, showing its dating provides greatly enhanced, that have Arthur happy to discover John and his awesome loved ones try in the end are along with her. While in the an arbitrary stagecoach burglary Micah Bell speculates one to John you certainly will getting turning on the fresh group and you will highlights the fresh new doubts Arthur has of him, but Arthur retorts that he is understood your to have a long time that he has no doubts, indicating you to definitely, even with exactly what John got carried out in for the last, as well as how Arthur thought about any of it, he nonetheless understands John would never betray the fresh group.